Destiny’s Lack of Social Grace


For a game that encourages interaction, Destiny needs to help you communicate better. 

I was one of the many who played the Destiny beta last week and I too found it to be a wonderful experience.  Bungie knows how to craft a sci-fi world that looks to be rich in lore and story telling.  Destiny was also very mechanically sound and it felt good both exploring the world and shooting the bad guys.  For all the good that was in Destiny there were still several aspects that I found to be a little lacking.

Although Bungie has denied calling Destiny a MMO the game certainly does borrow from that genre.  Its online only state with everyone inhabiting and exploring the same over world  and special, instanced spaces for missions are all classic marks of a MMO.  I am reminded a little bit of the game Defiance, the MMO/TPS hybrid.  In both games there are story missions, explorations and special missions to partake in all over the game map.  Destiny also features a wealth of loot to find in the form of weapons and armour that, just like any good MMO, will keep people grinding away to get that ultimate piece.

Destiny Characters

It may not be a MMO, but Destiny is meant to be enjoyed with others and is much more fun when playing in a group.

Bungie may call it a “shared-world shooter”, but the influence of MMOs is certainly there.  It is lacking once crucial piece however, social interactions in Destiny were horribly limited.  To be fair when you were grouped up with players you could all communicate with a mic, though I never heard anyone speak on any of the missions I played.  Beyond the simple emotes of point, wave and dance there was no way to communicate with other players not in your fire team.  The lack of a proximity voice chat or ideally a text chat I found to be a very odd choice for a game that was channeling so much of the MMO style.

Granted I am not always interested in talking to the random strangers I meet in games but it would be nice to have the option to say “thanks” when one revives me or say “good job!” when we successfully take out a Devil Walker in a public event.  It was extremely frustrating to play the one Strike mission available in the beta and have no way of communicating with my teammates.  I suppose it wasn’t too bad because the mission itself was not terribly hard and by the end of the beta people knew exactly what to do.

Destiny-11

The lone Strike mission in the beta was simple enough even without communication but having a simple text chat would have removed just about any and all hiccups I encountered.

Destiny is a game that will be compared to MMOs whether Bungie wants it too or not and at least right now it is far too difficult to communicate with other players.  I appreciate that Bungie is maybe also trying to cut out on the annoyance that is constantly listening to whiny players who do nothing but spout profanities and offensives jokes but there has to be a better way then limiting communication to only voice chat among a three person fire team.

Honestly as I played through the beta I could not help but think that all my complaints about communication could be solved by a simple text chat system.  Text chat is the standard for PC games and while its no where near as prevalent on consoles pretty much any keyboard with a USB connection would take care of any typing needs.  Or there are other peripherals you can buy to make typing easier on a console.  This was just another item to add to a list of why I wish Destiny was also coming to the PC.

Destiny is a great game that I enjoyed every minute I played during the beta and wish I could play more.  But its very poor communication system needs to be addressed before the final release of the game.  It is one of the few negatives I could find but it is a very important one.

About these ads

About Paul

Paul Stehlin is a Gamemoir writer who likes to spend all day talking about games and not much else. Find him on Twitter at @sharkboy421 or on his own blog at corrin.blog.com

There are 2 comments

  1. Nick Verboon

    There are bows and salutes that fill the “thank you/you’re welcome” role in communication, but I do wish you could customize your emotes so that each player could communicate exactly what they want to other players. More aggressive players and friendlier ones could each have their own sets to express themselves with instead of relying on the ones they are assigned. I think that the ability to mark objects and enemies like in Gears would have been a great addition too.

    Like

  2. Paul

    Yeah some way of marking an enemy would have been great as well. Would have been very useful to tell your teammates “hey we’ve got an ultra enemy over here”.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s